Laura’s Rating: 4/5 Stars
I recently reviewed the book Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier. I briefly mentioned the 1940 Alfred Hitchcock film based on the novel and decided to do a review for the movie as well.
The Analysis:
The movie version of Rebecca emphasizes the dark shadows and sense of gothic foreboding rather than the flowers and beauty of the Manderley estate. That is likely a choice by director Alfred Hitchcock, not known for cheery romances, but rather for the dark and sinister. It works well for the film and adds to the oppressive feeling of the spirit of Rebecca. The movie has some great shots of Rebecca’s belongings scattered throughout the house, making it feel as if she is still there. The movie won the Academy Award for best picture and an Oscar for best cinematography.
As a stand alone film, Rebecca is 4 stars. I also gave the book 4 stars, but when compared to each other, I prefer the novel. Sections of the novel are certainly omitted in the film, likely due to length. Even at just over 2 hours, the movie could never cover the entirety of events and thoughts contained within the novel. I think the movie left out or glossed over a few events that really set the tone for me in the book. However, the major events of the book are present and the actors fit well into their roles. Joan Fontaine plays the innocent and uncertain second Mrs. de Winter well and really portrays the way she feels overwhelmed and unsure of herself at Manderley. Judith Anderson delivers a great performance of Mrs. Danvers, perfectly portraying her character as written in the book: ill-intentioned and upset, yet never directly impolite.
One significant detail about the twist is changed in the movie, which I did not enjoy. I find that it softens the drama and intrigue. However, I think that the detailed setup in the novel is what allows for such a dramatic twist so it makes sense that the movie would have to change it slightly. The film version of Rebecca alters some events and removes many of the complexities of the story, but it does deliver an extra-dramatic ending. I recommend reading the book first but the movie is enjoyable even without the book.
Comments